1200 + 2800 Montauk Highway Brookhaven, New York
Listed By 365 Realty Group Inc
The Commercial Property for Sale located at Brookhaven, New York is currently for sale. Brookhaven, New York is listed for $3,300,000. If the property located at Brookhaven, New York isn't what you're looking for, visit https://blueislandhomesny.xomio.com to see other Commercial Properties for Sale in Brookhaven .
Date Updated : Apr 9, 2025
MLS#: 845756
$3,300,000 USD
Property features
Other features
- Cooling system: Central AC
- Heating system: Oil Propane
Description
Incredible opportunity to own a multi-use commercial property on busy Montauk Hwy in Brookhaven. Sitting on 1.58 acres across two separate lots (can be sold together or individually), this high-visibility property features an operating gas station, a vacant mechanic shop with 3 drive-in bays, a leased deli/restaurant with commercial kitchen, 2-story dwelling with basement, and an additional storage unit.
The gas station is active and pumping approx. 55,000 gallons/month, with tanks owned and inspected annually. The mechanic shop is currently not in use and ready for a new operator or tenant—great income potential. The deli is leased, with lottery license in place and liquor license in process, and includes a 5% annual rent increase. The unit on Old South Country Rd is tenant-occupied on a month-to-month lease at with separately paid utilities. Estimated rental income for the entire property exceeds $24,000/month when fully occupied.
Zoned Commercial, this is a rare offering ideal for investors, owner-operators, or developers seeking value-add or long-term hold in a strategic location. Property is being sold as-is. Survey available upon request.
For more info or to schedule a private showing, contact the listing agent directly.
Location
Listing Contact: 631-863-1111
